Old 09-12-2015, 05:34 AM
Ceno's Avatar
Ceno Ceno is offline
Join Date: Jul 2014
Posts: 9,784
Default Everything Cadence

Preface: It's 1:30AM and I have a writer's block on work which might be considered "productive" so everything below is likely to be some jumbled up rambling. Bare with me.

I've been thinking about Cadence a lot. I mean, actually, A LOT. With recent updates (B27 and related Hotfixes), Cadence has been tampered with a bunch but there hasn't been very much discussion on it. Yet I feel there's so much to talk about. So, let me start by throwing down a table of contents:
  1. Energy Cost
  2. Discord
  3. Dual Wield
  4. Sword + Board
  5. Conclusion
1. The newfound Energy Cost of Cadence has seen some discussion, but I wouldn't consider any results (if there were any) to be substantial. When the subject was first broached, I argued that the introduction of the energy cost was a step in the right direction and that Cadence very much deserved to play the energy management game. I still maintain that opinion.

But having leveled up a new Cadence build from 1-50, I'm finding it a little worrisome. I mean, I haven't (yet) burnt myself out or been forced into Energy Potion range, but I have gotten low in extensive combat, particularly against the Dermapterans where one is virtually consistently being attacked from several swarming enemies. Its bothersome, certainly, but hasn't yet been prohibitive.

Probably the most annoying piece to it is that every attack, whether utilizing the Cadence strike or not, deducts one's Energy. I'm not really a fan of this. I'd rather see only the Cadence attack itself cost Energy, and in turn see an increase to the Energy Cost to compensate. This would feel better, from a gameplay perspective.

2. There's been a lot of talk with Discord to revamp it on account of the new Conversion mechanics. There's problems with that, however. How much physical damage ought to be converted? How much of that which is converted is split between Chaos and Elemental Damage? I don't have reasonable answers for this.

Discord has always gotten a lot of flack for generally being very bad. This is still the case, in my opinion. Perhaps one solution to all of these problems would be to forget about conversion altogether and instead turn to the "%damage modified" stat. A reduction to Physical Damage% on Cadence (as Discord presently has) along with a positive Damage Modification Multiplier could better promote magical Cadence builds. Magical builds could still convert off the reduced-Physical Damage, too, with gearing/IEE/SWF.

But is Discord the right transmuter for Cadence to possess? Leaving this question unanswered until point 5.

3. Dual Wield Cadence was too strong. It's very much more balanced now, due to the reduction in Cadence's damage and the transfer of DW procs from Physical to Piercing orientation. But how much balancing is too much? Yes, DW Cadence was brought to a reasonable level, but what are the ramifications of that?

4. Sword and Board Cadence has taken a very large hit due to the DW Cadence balancing. Pistol/Shield Cadence is in an even worse position, as it lacks the AoE component of Fighting Form. The reduction of Physical Damage and Weapon Damage has seriously crippled the ability of such builds to reach respectable offensive potential.

One could argue that you can't have it all. One could argue that the defensive potential of shields is so great that some offensive sacrifices need to be made. Both arguments would be true; however, its not that equipping a shield reduces the damage one does. It's that DW and 2H Cadence is still taking full advantage of Cadence's potential due to [very high attack speed]/[very high base damage], respectively. Whereas utilizing one weapon + an offhand does not allow one to capitalize on Cadence's strengths well enough, and so the recent nerfs to Cadence's innate power seriously dampened the potential of these builds.

5. So what conclusions do I draw from all of this?

To recap, we have
  1. A pretty bad transmuter
  2. Balanced DW/2H
  3. Underpowered 1H/offhand
To me, this sounds like the perfect position for a new transmuter to take Discord's place.

So, scrap Discord, buff Cadence back to where it was damage-wise (keeping the energy cost, or adjusting it as mentioned in point 1.), but make Cadence innately not function when utilizing DW (melee; ranged is fine imo because no AoE) weapons. In turn, add a new transmuter that reduces the effectiveness of Cadence but grants the ability to wield two (melee) weapons and use the skill. DW was never part of the innate Soldier mastery anyways, but that's what transmuters are for, right?

This could put Sword/Pistol + Board Cadence back in a respectable position while keeping DW Cadence balanced. Maybe tack 2H onto the transmuter as well, but that's kind of awkward because 2H DOES fit with the Soldier mastery and it wouldn't make much sense to not be able to use it at first.

Edit: Alternatively, keep Cadence as it is, but make the transmuter required a shield and grant some bonus offensive potential. This could be a simpler change.


Discuss, as you will. If anything is unclear, let me know and I'll try to clarify my thoughts after giving my head a rest. Cheers!

Last edited by Ceno; 09-12-2015 at 05:44 AM.
Old 09-12-2015, 06:19 AM
Manic Wolf's Avatar
Manic Wolf Manic Wolf is offline
Join Date: Nov 2014
Posts: 177

Cadence's problem was that it was a balanced skill. It correctly accounted for the Soldier's inherent lack of damage by giving him a steady "falcon punch" when he needed it (back before NB or 2handed weapons were even introduced).

That being said, with the inclusion of factors outside of the original design, the skill became ridiculously OP when used with DWing. So I'm with you on the change in transmuter. It's just that I'd love for elemental/choas/aether Cadence to be a viable choice (especially as a Battlemage/Witchblade taking Soldier as more complementary rather than primary).
Old 09-12-2015, 06:44 AM
jalex3's Avatar
jalex3 jalex3 is offline
Join Date: May 2012
Posts: 441

"scrap Discord" Please don't. Its great with witchblades and battlemages.
Old 09-12-2015, 07:27 AM
Marney's Avatar
Marney Marney is offline
Join Date: Oct 2013
Posts: 1,388

Yeah, not sure why Discord is getting any hate. I think it's a pretty good transmuter.

I don't really think 1H Cadence needs to be buffed relative to 2H because the inherent attack speed makes it trigger more often. I switch between 1H and 2H setups depending on what I'm fighting and they seem equally good to me.
You can't always get what you want
Old 09-12-2015, 08:05 AM
Palarmutsi Palarmutsi is offline
Join Date: Jul 2015
Posts: 17

I have 1hander + shield soldier. I dont have any problems with him, I only hated that my block dmg reduced 300 since B27. it used to be around 1300-1500.
Old 09-12-2015, 08:10 AM
corporateslave corporateslave is offline
Join Date: Jun 2015
Posts: 131

Originally Posted by Marney View Post
I don't really think 1H Cadence needs to be buffed relative to 2H because the inherent attack speed makes it trigger more often. I switch between 1H and 2H setups depending on what I'm fighting and they seem equally good to me.
I beg to differ. Ceno's post prompted me to try out my sword and board Cadence battlemage which I haven't touched since B26. He lost ~1/3 of his damage and now has mana issues (chugging mana pots slightly more frequently than he finds them). I could solve the mana problems with some gear swaps or by placing points in IEE, but I'll lose even more damage if I do.

I'm thinking I'll go back to using a 2-hander because the DPS loss from wearing a shield doesn't currently justify the increased survivability. Although I might feel differently if I played HC Vet instead of regular Vet.
Old 09-12-2015, 08:59 AM
adoomgod's Avatar
adoomgod adoomgod is offline
Join Date: Mar 2013
Posts: 2,245

Sword and board is suppose to be slower but tankier. I'm not saying you're wrong, but could you give me a one handed skill from the soldier tree that's better than cadence? Is that even a bad thing?

Soldiers are so fricken good and tanky. They shouldnt have equal damage to other class trees.

But if you're saying the loss for sword and boarders is TOO great, that's another story. There shouldn't be a huge disparity. Is forcewave not fine for shield users?

My dualwield and two handed cadence builds are definitely fine.
Old 09-12-2015, 09:04 AM
jackx jackx is offline
Join Date: May 2015
Posts: 222

The only real use for Discord I could see is with minimal investment in Cadence itself on a caster weapon, so you spent 5 points total for a double-hit every third strike and +100% chaos/elemental. That'd likely be a build where melee attacks aren't your main damage source, though.

With conversion, at the skill stage of damage calculation, you want more phyiscal damage, not less, and you want %dmg to be applied from gear/attributes, after converting from your (high) physical damage.

Then there's the fact that conversion unsupported by skills isn't very appealing, and both auto-attack replacers do a much better job at supporting their associated magical damage type than Cadence ever could.

Discord was designed for when stacking large amounts of flat magical damage was how you made a non-physical melee build...
Old 09-13-2015, 05:52 AM
Tooopy Tooopy is offline
Join Date: Jan 2015
Posts: 188

I think Discord should add flat elemental damage, and reduce total damage, or something similar. Flat elemental damage would scale better than a % with any weapon.

Perhaps have a flat Elemental damage and then a chance to roll a % increase to ele on attack.

Originally Posted by Ceno View Post

4. Sword and Board Cadence has taken a very large hit due to the DW Cadence balancing.Pistol/Shield Cadence is in an even worse position, as it lacks the AoE component of Fighting Form
I think this is a fault with ranged weaponry and not Cadence its self, and I don't think Cadence is the way to fix this. The only time ranged weapons get an AoE is from fire strike or item skills.

Last edited by Tooopy; 09-13-2015 at 05:54 AM.
Old 09-13-2015, 04:49 PM
Altolong Altolong is offline
Join Date: Nov 2014
Posts: 166

I'm in agreement for the actual Cadence proc to cost mana rather than the normal hits when you use Cadence.
I thought Discord gave you a boost to elemental damage and/or chaos damage rather than convert the physical damage into the aforementioned other damage types.
I don't think Cadence needs another transmuter. Overguard should have longer duration and shorter cooldown.
Closed Thread

balance, cadence

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

Grim Dawn ©2019 Crate Entertainment, LLC.
vBulletin® 3.8.4 ©2000-2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.